This comment page has a white background for printing purposes.
You may also make your comment via the [Permalink].
Bookmark and Share
Entry:> ... and the moral of the story is? Monday, April 26, 2004



Lisa Ling is a hottie!
How FUN is this?

A discussion over at Plastic points out a recent Wired.com article by Daniel Terdiman, Playing Games With a Conscience:

In it, Terdiman mentions the release of the Simon Wiesanthal Center's annual report, Digital Terrorism and Hate 2004, which the SWC is selling for $20.00 in CD-format.  I'm big on free information on the internet, especially if it is important enough, so I'm a littled irked that the SWC expects me to pay for its "report".  Other than that, I can't comment on it.  All I can do is not give them a free link to their store.  Terdiman also quotes an essayist, Noah Wardrip-Fruin, about Newsgaming.com's September 12th game:

the goal of the game is to develop in the player "empathy for the people who will become terrorists out of that experience, of having seen innocent people killed."

Basically, the game goes like this:  You're the U.S. military.  The terrorists are in the village.  You shoot the terrorists and inevitably kill innocent bystanders.  Other people in the village see this and then become terrorists, too.  The point of the September 12th game is, as near as I can fathom, that you kill Osama and a thousand more take his place.

Empathy is one thing.  Teaching your kids that the U.S. military is in a no-win situation while someone's relatives are actually fighting in (Fallujah) Iraq, right now, is up to you.  Newsgaming.com also recently released a Madrid game.  Its goal is to "homage the victims of the Madrid terror attacks, as well as all the other cities that have  experienced these hideous crimes."

While Wardrip-Fruin may be a Brown scholar and believes that the popularity of online gaming may be a way to communicate ideas since the straight-text e-book has flopped commercially for the most part,  I partially disagree.  Blogs, which are predominately text, have become huge.  In addition, while I could perhaps imagine myself having a little empathy for someone's situation, if say, I was reading their Trapped in Fallajuh blog, I think it's in poor taste to turn the War on Terror or the Madrid Bombing into a videogame to begin with.  But maybe that's just me.

And finally, I thought games were just supposed to be fun, right?

[> permalink <]

   3 comments

Duke
April 28, 2004   08:25 PM PDT
 
The whole empathy thing sounds like Liberal rhetoric to me. So what, were supposed to feel bad because our troops go out of their way to avoid civilian casualties yet the terrorists use civilians as human shields and then blame us for the civilian death toll? C'mon now, why don't we just stop the war on terror and let the terrorists do whatever it is they want, they're prolly just going thru a phase or perhaps it's ADD so lets drop medipacks filled with Ritalin. I mean heck that's their solution for a whole generation of normal kids who are 'out of control' simply because their parents refuse to discipline them! I agree with you that making a video game out of the War and/or the Madrid Bombing is in extremely poor taste.
The Lib
April 28, 2004   09:01 PM PDT
 
The market will take care of these folks. And they'll learn the hard way.
J f Z
July 20, 2004   02:37 AM PDT
 
[update] I found a better link to Noah Wardrip-Fruin today at his own site Hypertext.Org and added it to this entry.

Leave a Comment:

Name


Homepage (optional)


Comments






Bookmark and Share