John Furie Zacharias
having a bad day in a strange place
Thunderstorms Anywhere

Thunderstorms in the Imajica



 The different ways I don't like you 
 in a list that may never become organized
[Search Topics]

[Bush] [Fraggin']
[Iraq] [Conspiracy]
[Florida] [Evil Thumbnails]
[Iran] [Sex]
[NASA] [Movies]
[Politics] [GooTube]
[Media] [TIDGADA]
[Sports] [LBOH]



[Tag Board] [Archives]
   
<< December 2007 >>
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
 01
02 03 04 05 06 07 08
09 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
30 31

JfZ making a mess of the web
[@twitter] [@facebook]
[@playlist] [@plastic]
[@vodpod] [@zazzle]
[helpforum] [web-litter]
[verissimus] [morphine dreams]
[dark skies] [brilliant weeds]


Phreek-went Phaves
[blogs] [ezines] [rtmfd]
[eye candy] [ear candy]
[mind candy]

[Buy Thunderstorms Gear]
Get Some Effin' Gear

[Supported Causes]





Add to My Yahoo!
[+ favorites]
AddThis Feed Button
rss feed


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License.

Privacy Policy


If you want to be updated on this weblog Enter your email here:

Tuesday, December 11, 2007
Stans: Valley of Death


Korengal valley

Click here for hi-rez image (photo: defenselink.mil)

"Into the Valley of Death" is the title of Sebastian Junger's latest investigative article in Vanity Fair magazine in which he follows the redeployment of Battle Company, 2nd Battalion, 503rd Infantry (Airborne), 173rd Airborne Brigade Combat Team, Task Force Rock, to Afghanistan's Korengal Valley.

Junger, an experienced war correspondent and author, reported on Battle company's previous deployment in Afghanistan and thought it would be a very good idea to simply document this recent deployment as a follow-up.  Junger certainly has the experience to comment on the bigger picture of the power struggles and strategic decisions concerning Afghanistan.  He weaves that big picture into the narrative of the compelling personal stories of the men of Battle company.

A strategic passage wanted by the Taliban and al-Qaeda, Afghanistan's Korengal Valley is among the deadliest pieces of terrain in the world for U.S. forces.  One platoon is considered the tip of the American spear. Its men spend their days in a surreal combination of backbreaking labor—building outposts on rocky ridges—and deadly firefights, while they try to avoid the mistakes the Russians made.  Sebastian Junger and photographer Tim Hetherington join the platoon's painfully slow advance, as its soldiers laugh, swear, and run for cover, never knowing which of them won't make it home.
 
Sebastian Junger, Vanity Fair, January 2008

 

Bushworld "Strategery" ...

One of things that compels me to comment on Junger's Vanity Fair article, "Into the Valley of Death," is that I share some of the opinions that Junger seems to bring up in his article.  It's not just a domestic political partisan argument to say that the Bush administration redirected its focus to Iraq, at the expense of Afghanistan.  That's a well documented fact.  It's going to be a strategic foreign policy nightmare if Afghanistan becomes a failed state once again from inattention. 

Not even going into the foolishness of Charlie Wilson's War and the blowback that became 9-11, we (the U.S.A.) then outsourced the overthrow of the Taliban to tribal leaders of the so-called Northern Alliance in contact with our CIA.  And now we're outsourcing the reconstruction to our N.A.T.O. allies because Bush, Cheney, and Rumsfeld had their own ambitions for the future of Iraq since their first day at work in 2001.  This outsourcing relieves Bush of direct responsibility for the outcome of his own decisions.

The other very obvious common sense point Junger makes in his article is that al-Qaeda and Taliban leaders are safe and sound and living in nearby Quetta, in Pakistan.  Politicians and U.S. media tend to make things sound too complicated.  It's over there in Central Asia, it's confusing.  We spend a trillion dollars to accomplish nothing as long as no one takes any responsibliity.

We scattered al-Qaeda and Taliban, we didn't defeat them militarily or politically.  They don't live in caves.  They live in nice apartments in Quetta, Pakistan.  Wahabbi extremists fly into Pakistan, train, and then deploy to Afghanistan and Iraq.  They are funded by the same oil money that funded 9-11.  It's a disconnect between elite political allies and the people of these countries.  Bush and Musharraf may be dictator buddies, but that doesn't mean that people on the ground in each of their countries don't work constantly toward regime change.

 

Personal Stories

The other reason I recommend "Into the Valley of Death" to you is to check out the photography of Tim Hetherington.  As I was reading Junger's article, I had Hetherington's portrait photographs of the men of Battle company in another window to put a face on the stories and I clicked back and forth ...

Other than my strategic ranting, I don't want to characterize or summarize the article.  It's very well written.  It's compelling, and I prefer you just click through and read it for yourself.

"Into the Valley of Death" is only a six page article on the web, but if you need a teaser to convince you to read it, check out the short video here.

 

[ headphones ]  - Sinja's Project Playlist

      

 


Posted at 08:55 am by John Furie Zacharias

Daveman
December 11, 2007   10:55 AM PST
 
I just wonder where Bush's war strategy comes from..
A personal agenda working in conflict with reality Im guessing. The man is a complete dissapointment - a dangerous one.
J f Z
December 11, 2007   05:29 PM PST
 
The House Armed Services Committee actually held a 3-hour long hearing on "Security and Stability in Afghanistan: Status of U.S. Strategy and Operations and the Way Ahead" this afternoon adter I published this entry today. The video of that should be available soon on the C-Span.org web site if you want to know more about the current status.
jude
December 14, 2007   12:27 PM PST
 
i scanned junger's article--will read it in depth in a bit--and saw hetherington's excellent fotos...

it all reminded me of a superb television series, "band of men" and the extraordinary reaction i had at the end, listening to the real survivors speak, seeing fotos of those that died...no words to describe the feelings they elicited. it personalized the face of war, as did hetherington's portraits.
jude
December 14, 2007   12:34 PM PST
 
eh...not enough coffee, i think

'band of brothers'...

argh
J f Z
December 14, 2007   02:44 PM PST
 
/pours Jude coffee. /sips vodka. I just love the timezone difference we share.

I do think that Junger's article is one of the most personalized pieces of reporting I've read in a long time. I commend his idea to follow the same men back to Afghanistan.

I watched the recent congressional hearing. While it is true that our government should be able to walk and chew gum and the same time, I don't think they're pulling that level of coordination off very well.
 

Leave a Comment:

Name


Homepage (optional)


Comments




Bookmark and Share



 
Previous Entry Home Next Entry